The state of the New York subway

By Stephen Donahue

The New York City subway system, a vital artery of the city’s transportation network, is facing a growing challenge: the rise of inconsiderate behavior. Commuters are speaking out against the lack of basic etiquette, making their daily rides increasingly uncomfortable and inconvenient.

Cell phones and electronic devices have become a fundamental part of daily life, transforming how people interact, work, and enjoy leisure activities. Yet their pervasive influence has also contributed to a surge in distractions and inconsiderate behavior. During the pandemic, worldwide phone usage increased significantly, and this trend has continued in recent years. However, the constant use of these devices in public spaces like the MTA subway can lead to a lack of awareness about one’s current surroundings. For instance, people often stand close to the edge of the platform or block train doors.

The issue is not just about annoyance; it also affects safety. When people block doors or stand too close to the edge of the platform, it can lead to accidents. Moreover, the stress and tension caused by inconsiderate behavior can contribute to a rise in altercations. In recent years, complaints about inconsiderate behavior have surged. Riders are frustrated with people who refuse to give up their seats to those in need, who play music without using headphones, and who litter without regard for others. This trend is not only annoying but also contributes to a hostile environment that can escalate to more serious incidents.

“I’ve seen people get into fights over seats or because someone was playing music too loudly,” said Jane Smith, a daily commuter from Brooklyn. “It’s like people have forgotten how to be respectful of others in public spaces.”

To combat this growing issue, experts suggest a multi-faceted approach. First, the MTA should increase public awareness campaigns, reminding riders of basic subway etiquette through posters, announcements, and digital ads. Second, enforcement of existing rules must be strengthened, whether through the presence of transit police or dedicated staff trained to handle minor disputes and enforce conduct policies. Additionally, community engagement programs that encourage respectful behavior and peer accountability could help foster a more considerate commuting culture. Without these combined efforts, the problem of irresponsible behavior is likely to worsen, further diminishing the quality and safety of subway rides.

Manskar, N. (2019, October 21). Win $500 for photos of Trash-Filled NYC subway trains. New York City, NY Patch.

The NYPD has reported an increase in subway-related incidents, including assaults and harassment. While these numbers are still relatively low compared to other crimes, they reflect a broader societal trend where public spaces are becoming increasingly volatile. According to a recent survey, over 70% of commuters reported experiencing some form of inconsiderate behavior on their daily rides. The most common complaints included people blocking doors, playing loud music, and failing to yield seats to those who need them more. The MTA has rules of conduct in place to address issues like littering, smoking, and creating nuisances. However, these rules are essentially meaningless as they are rarely enforced.